NY&A ISL

[Brakie]

I'd drop spur 2 and extend spur 1 to have maybe 2 customers.

I thought of doing it that way also but that might require a longer extension, at least that's how the track cad makes it look but to me they don't seem that accurate and once I start building I will look into making one long siding. And yes it will be modern/present day era.

I would opt for a second or even a third car spot like for( say) a covered hopper or tank car which is far superior to the old school " let's play jam the industries on one industrial siding" designing thoughts..

I like your plan as it is now.