Just Sayin...

[eightyeightfan1]

These things simply don't help someone improve.
I've always found an honest evaluation beats the use of some off the wall "smilie".

If they've done a superb job ?, " nicely done " ( with or without the smilie )

If there's room for improvement ?, " Next time, give this brief how-to a try, and see if it works a little better for you ".
could provide a suggested path for doing it better.



Let's keep it a bit more 'positive'.

How many posts have you seen say that. We're such a nice bunch of guys, that bashing someone's work, or giving a little constructive help, is beyond our personalities.
And if someone did say: "That's a piece of crap! If I were you I'd throw it away and start all over again. See if you can it right the second time.", Just imagine the replies that guy would get.