04-04-2010, 06:31 PM
Didn't realize the extent of a firestorm this would create...
More or less.
I admit my interests are influenced by what I've been exposed to, though mostly not first-hand. And I suppose I let myself feel somehow superior for treating non-local railroads equally - and I sometimes feel guilty for not giving some foreign railroads a chance!
I suppose I'm influenced by the perception that, at some fairly recent time, most steam-era modellers were old enough to personally remember it. I guess that isn't true anymore.
Quote:I'm trying to reconcile your annoyance with nostalgia with your signature line that professes being a fan of the 40-50s PRR.Just kidding, but I am curious about the comment about an "unhealthy level" of nostalgia. Are you suggesting that the American tendency to model the transition from steam to diesel is overdone? Too cliche'?
More or less.
I admit my interests are influenced by what I've been exposed to, though mostly not first-hand. And I suppose I let myself feel somehow superior for treating non-local railroads equally - and I sometimes feel guilty for not giving some foreign railroads a chance!
I suppose I'm influenced by the perception that, at some fairly recent time, most steam-era modellers were old enough to personally remember it. I guess that isn't true anymore.
Quote:Interesting. In what ways do you feel you are oppressed?On some forums, both some I'm a member of and some I just read sometimes, there are a lot of political statements. Most are conservative, pro-war or anti-environmentalist (except for being pro-rail). On sites which nominally discourage political discussion. I get the feeling that, if I were to make what I consider equally politicized statements reflecting my views, I wouldn't be welcomed.
Fan of late and early Conrail... also 40s-50s PRR, 70s ATSF, BN and SP, 70s-80s eastern CN, pre-merger-era UP, heavy electric operations in general, dieselized narrow gauge, era 3/4 DB and DR, EFVM and Brazilian railroads in general... too many to list!

Just kidding, but I am curious about the comment about an "unhealthy level" of nostalgia. Are you suggesting that the American tendency to model the transition from steam to diesel is overdone? Too cliche'?