Southern Pacific Switching Layout

[Justinmiller171]

So here are the two track-plans I am deciding between for the Rahway Valley Industrial Railroad(RVI)

1.
Pros:
It is an entire short-line
Lots of room for scenery
interesting operation
Cons:
Stuck with modeling a short-line
Doesn't use some of my favorite rolling stock


2.
Pros:
Uses all of my rolling stock
Includes some of my favorite industries
Able to model almost any railroad I want(Including a shortline)
Includes staging area
Cons:
Compressed
No interchange
Not as much room for scenery